The Good Place is filled to the brim with continuity errors and plot holes, but this does nothing to damage its overall themes. The series is an outrageous comedy that pokes fun at human civilization and the concepts of philosophy. However, through its complex plot, it often seems to forget its own rules and contradicts itself around every corner. Typically, this would lead critics to tear a show apart, but in the case of The Good Place, the continuity errors only enhance the show's overall point.

https://screenrant.com/good-place-continuity-plot-holes-good/