One of the most important positions in MLB The Show 23, the best Starting Pitcher has to be an athlete with some of the top stats for players to set a positive tone for a game early. To make sure talented opponents on the other team don't nail home runs through tricky throws, Pitchers have to be versatile. Starting Pitchers, on the other hand, have to also be able to last multiple innings as such intense throws can take a toll on any athlete's stamina.