During Criminal Minds‘ 16 seasons, many cast members left for various reasons but fans still wonder things like, “why did Gideon leave Criminal Minds?” The show is a popular police procedural drama that follows a group of criminal profilers working for the Behavioral Analysis Unit in the FBI. The show premiered in 2005 on CBS and had a mostly successful run. Widely considered one of the best procedural TV shows, Criminal Minds remained popular because of its exciting plot lines and engaging characters. Unfortunately, many of those characters eventually left the show.